SODIS
Passive Solar Disinfection
|
Cheap; reuse bottles; simple |
Water is warm; have to wait for water; turbidity sensitive |
$ |
High |
http://www.survivaltopics.com/survival/solar-water-disinfection/
http://www.sodis.ch/methode/anwendung/index_EN
|
Plastic Biosand Filters |
Effective; once primed provide quick water treatment |
Time needed to develop biofilm; skill required to maintain; support needed; turbidity sensitive |
$$$$$ |
Moderate |
http://www.hydraid.org/ |
Concrete Biosand Filters |
Effective; once primed provide quick water; can usually be built in country with local materials |
Heavy and difficult to transport and move; skill required; turbidity sensitive |
$$$$ |
Moderate |
Biosand Filter.org Fact Sheet |
Chlorine |
Very effective when used properly; cheap |
Bad taste to water; skill required; potential negative health impacts; doses vary depending on product being used |
$ |
High |
http://www.ag.ndsu.edu/pubs/h2oqual/watsys/ae1046w.htm |
Boiling
Rolling Boil for 1-3 minutes
|
Very effective at killing most pathogens |
Expensive; contributes to deforestation; have to cool water before drinking |
$$$ |
Moderate |
http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/page/water-treatment.htm |
Reverse Osmosis |
Very effective at removing all pathogens |
Very expensive; requires consistent fuel or power; skill required; maintenance required |
$$$$$$ |
Low |
Water Treatment Notes from Cornell University |
Sawyer Filters |
Very effective;
Easy to use when proper education materials are provided
|
Expensive; may have to sterilize filters regularly; not well suited
for areas with turbid water; backwashing can cause contamination |
$$$ |
Moderate |
http://www.sawyer.com/water.htm |
Clay Filters |
Cheap and can be made from local materials |
Clay quality can affect treatment; skill required; may not be effective for some viruses and bacteria |
$ |
High |
http://www.pottersforpeace.org/?page_id=9 |
Ultraviolet Disinfection |
Very effective; power requirements low (~ 200 watts for 40 gpm) |
Flow rates low; can be complicated to install; maintenance required for bulbs |
$$$$ |
High/Moderate |
http://www.freshwatersystems.com/c-616-atlantic-ultraviolet-sanitron.aspx
http://www.ultraviolet.com/water/minipu01.htm
|
Slow sand filtration |
Can be scaled to larger water sources for schools and communities |
Initial costs are high and require materials which may not be available on-site |
$$$$ |
High/Moderate |
Tech Brief from the National Environmental Services Center |
Ozone Disinfection |
Does not create harmful byproducts; does not alter taste; no residual chemicals |
On-site equipment required is expensive and requires maintenance; ozone is reactive and corrosive |
$$$$$$ |
Low |
EPA fact sheet on Ozone Dissinfection |
|
|
|
|
|
|